Please log in this format (please don't change this example just copy and paste it]: -------- [title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab [nick of the observer angel] -------- [timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement] ... [timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends --> [Conclusion here] _____________________________________________________ -------- From Zero To Zero Day segal -------- [timestamp system time 11:30] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time 11:31] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time 11:35] presentation shown too short [timestamp system time 11:39] presentation shown too short [timestamp system time 12:12] switch back to speaker faster [timestamp system time 12:15] sound of the audience questions could be better [timestamp system time 12:18] talk ends --> [Conclusion here] video mixer is a fast reader :-); nothing to complain about, audio was a little bit behind video, but was tolerable _____________________________________________________ -------- Kosmische Teilchenbeschleuniger und ihre Spuren in der Antarktis segal -------- [timestamp system time 12:50] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time 12:50] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time 12:55] sudden camera move [timestamp system time 12:57] picture is moving up and down a little bit (shaking) [timestamp system time 12:59] presentation should be full screen [timestamp system time 13:04] video behind audio [timestamp system time 13:35] video shaking [timestamp system time 13:37] presentation not visible, while they speak about it [timestamp system time 13:39] talk ends --> [Conclusion here] everything alright, camera shaking due to walking people should be avoided _____________________________________________________ -------- Micropython - Python for Microcontrollers phail -------- [timestamp system time 14:10] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time 14:11] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time 14:12] Audio is not synchronous (video is lagging behind) - VOC Helpdesk informed [timestamp system time 14:22] Slide could be shown shorter * Which one? —pivot [timestamp system time 14:25] Audio is still asynchronous [timestamp system time 14:40] Q&A Starts [timestamp system time 14:41] Closeup Camera Cuts head sometimes, move camera up. Leave some space above head * In the mixer GUI, this was not visible (or at least I didn't notice). [timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends --> Good work, lots of movement from the speaker. Asynchronous audio is a huge Issue. When speaker is visible, quite Annoying. pivot (Mischer): * Insgesamt ist der Talk gefühlt gut verlaufen, die Kameraengel (snaums und haralk) haben gute Bilder geliefert, es gab keine größeren Schwierigkeiten. * Zu Beginn des Talks hat das Umschalten auf Kamera 1 mit F1 nicht funktioniert (nachdem es beim Testen funktioniert hat und auch die übrigen F-Tasten funktioniert haben). Der Fokus war definitiv in der GUI und nicht im Chat. Mit der Maus hat es dann funktioniert (und danach auch wieder per F1). * An den Tallies war nicht erkennbar, wann der Stream live ist. * Der Herald hat „Schnittmarke“ gesagt. Darauf war ich nicht vorbereitet und habe auf den Satzanfang geschnitten – das sollte vielleicht in der Einführung angekündigt werden. * Das Interkom stand auf der linken Seite, was bei der derzeitigen Tastenbelegung ungünstig ist (linke Hand an F1..F4 und am Interkom); die rechte Seite wäre besser. * 1-2 Schukodosen am Mischerplatz für DECT-Ladestation / Compter wären hilfreich. _____________________________________________________ In sowjet russia smart card hacks you Michos -------- [16:08] stream starts [16:08] Zoom in on the herald to not show the raised hands of the audience and too much headroom [16:11] herald introduces the speaker and talk [16:11] speaker starts the talk [16:27] too much headspace for the speaker [16:43] talk ends [16:46] nice and smooth panning of cam 1 [16:49] stream paused --> nice use of side by side. Timely switching between cams and slides. Nice camera work following the speaker and framing. Camera 2 was zoomed out way too much and also had too much head space. Overall pleasant to watch. Thanks for the nice work. Stream paused slightly too late. _____________________________________________________ Domain Name System - Hierarchical decentralized namingsystem used since 30 years HendriX -------- [17:11] herald introduces the speaker and talk [17:11] speaker starts the talk [17:15] side-by-side and pic-in-pic should be used depending on the free space in the presentation [17:20] long peroid of side-by-side-view is boring [17:25] still same view [17:30] so far cam 2 is not used at all ?!? [17:31] again back to side-by-side-view - just a short pic-in-pic break [17:36] 1st time cam2 for 5 seconds during the talk [17:44] total view at the end at q&a - could have been used more often to loosen up the presentation [17:51] good example for a change in view that could have been more often ... [17:53] talk ends --> quite dull experience, there were only few changes in views, no emotions are captured _____________________________________________________ Web-based Cryptojacking in the Wild incase -------- [18:08] stream starts with silent herald. [BAD: Audible 50Hz hum in stream] [18:09-18:10] Several announcements by herald, then starting to introduce speaker. Would have been nice to see introduction slide. [18:10] (Side note: No translations for this talk?) [18:12] Good use of PiP/Supersource [18:15] Might be good to switch to full screen slides occasionally. Remaining on PiP all the time is boring. And on low res, you don't get the slides or the speaked in reasonable resolution. [18:17] Still same composition [18:19] [Switch views occasionally, please. More specifically, try to show speaker full screen from time to time.] [18:22] Boring experience with almost always PiP [18:23] Not a closeup, but finally the speaker on full screen. Yay... [18:25] Oh, finally a close up view of the speaker. Thanks. [18:29] Good switch to PiP and later full-screen slides after relatively (nicely) long view of the speaker. [18:31] Good switching between full views of speaker and slights in sync with the talk progress. [18:34] Could have switched from mostly empty slide a bit earlier [18:36] Where is the PiP from the start of the talk? This slide would have really lent itself to its use. [18:39] Nice use of Pip [18:40] End of talk, Switch to full screen speaker. Would have been nice to see the end slide for a bit, which seemed to have contact info. [18:42] Audio: Question had odd audio issues which seemed a bit like noise reduction gone wild. [18:43] Good switching in general. Though switching to the speaker a bit more timely when the actual question (not the herald) comes up would be nice. [18:48] Good switch to slide when needed during Q&A. This can easily be missed by video mixers. [18:49] herald concludes the talk and does some announcements. Relatively harsh cut to pause while herald appeared to still be speaking. --> This felt like to different people doing the mixing: Very dull start with almost no change in image composition ever, then a good experience from 18:19 onwards. Only a few nitpicking comments on that part. Overall a good stream though. _____________________________________________________ Modeling and Simulation of Physical Systems for Hobbyists mfa -------- [19:10] herald introduces the speaker and talk [19:10] Audio is not synchronous (video is lagging behind) - VOC Helpdesk informed [19:11] speaker starts the talk [19:12] speaker is sitting. not in center of image, but a bit left. [19:14] showing slides only is maybe a good way to ignore the lagging [19:17] speaker in full screen. still lagging [19:18] showing slides in fullscreen again [19:25] cam1 in corner. audio still lagging. recognizable even in the small window [19:38] a question from from the audience. speaker doesn't repeat the question(s) [19:45] end of talk [19:45] start of questions. cam to full podium [19:46] echo at start of answer of speaker [19:47] end of q&a [19:48] end of stream overall a good stream. showing the slides and desktop of speaker most of the time was a good way to mitigate the audio lag. _____________________________________________________ Lecture: Remo2hbo -Robustes und reparierbares Vitalparametermonitoring snaums -------- [20:55] talk starts without audio (and slide-feed), I guess the harald introduced the speaker, can't be sure. [20:56] shows the slides by switching to camera 3(?), instead of using PIP, peoples heads are visible (aparently the slide-feed is broken) [20:58] speaker is _slightly_ out of center in closeup [21:03] camera 2 takes both speakers in shot, nice [21:05] audio now works, PIP now works [21:08] the slides have a black frame around them (designed so by the speakers), then cam1 as overlay could be better than PIP (with 35c3 background image) [21:14] mixer keeps a slide with a schematic overview of the system in PIP while the speaker talks about it, which is good [21:15] camera 2 could try to bring the desk in center (if the other speaker is still in shot then) [21:18] PIP with camera 2 - makes the speaker quite small [21:19] talk ends, Q&A / discussion begins [21:20] close-up on both speakers, good [21:21] camera 1 zoomed a bit out to keep both speakers in shot (zoom was not visible in stream) [21:26] camera 3 out of focus? [21:27] the camera on the speakers could try to center both speakers (make the margins between each speaker equally wide) -> fixed in next shot [21:30] in Q&A switched to PIP (while the speaker was not talking about the slide) [21:31] In Q&A switch between the mics a bit too late [21:33] switched to slides to show the URL of the project again, good [21:34] minor nitpick in organisation: one person of the project sits in the audience and what they said cannot be heard/understood in stream [21:39] harald ends the talk [21:40] stream ended on the last slide (URL), part of the announcement still on stream --> started with broken slide-feed (and audio), the framing by the cameras was done well, camera 3 seems to be slightly out of focus. Mixing was done well and the cameras did a good job. Overall a good stream, given the obstacles at the start _____________________________________________________ -------- Funkzellenabfrage: Die alltägliche Rasterfahndung unserer Handydaten Fox -------- 22:08 herald: defragmentation 22:08 camera does a nice and calm job following herald smoothly. nice framing. 22:10 defragmentation is in process, audio is live. seeing infobeamer is a bit funny :-) 22:10 herald introduces translation services 22:13 herald introduces the speaker and talk 22:13 camera could give herald more nose room 22:13 nice cut to speakers after introduction 22:13 speaker starts the talk 22:13 perfect cut to full frame slide Seehofer, when the speakers refer to him. Perfect! :-) 22:14 Nice PiP! Great! 22:15 Here I would have showed the slide w/o pIp, because the person on the slide is covered a bit, at least for a few seconds - just a feeling 22:16 Nice PiP with the scrolling slide information. Dramatic. Yeaha, great! 22:19 there is information covered on the slide. Would show the slide - at least for a few seconds, as full frame. Important information covered: Telekom! 0.. ? days. Source also covered. 22:22 nice PiP 22:22 low volume audio humm (50 Hz harmonics) in the background 22:34 .. 22:38 Stream Observer Engel ins Stream Observing eingewiesen (kein Observing) 22:38 PiP covers information on slide. Show slide full frame. - Fixed 10 seconds later :-) 22:39 overview camera seems a bit blurry ... maybe check focus 22:44 PiP covers person in slide. not really super important. But for me it would be nice, when shown in full frame 22:56 Short nice cut to full frame speakers 23:03 herald introduces Q&A 23:03 audio from speaker with hall 23:05 herold camera seems a bit dark. iris full open? maybe amplify video signal (dB-switch) 23:07 super very low volume audio humm (50 Hz harmonics) in the background 23:10 microphone not open on time 23:10 audio and video not in sync (video a bit too late) 23:11 talk ends 23:11 nice to have herald after the talk 23:12 nice and smooth ending of the talk. Great! --> Good use of PiP :-) Nice and calm camera framing before and throughout the talk. Nice and calm video mixing. Supports the viewer. Great, to have the full frame picture slides in full frame all the time. _____________________________________________________