It looks like you're having connection troubles. Reconnect now.
12/29/2018 00:45:02
streamObserver35C3-Tag2-HallD Latest text of pad streamObserver35C3-Tag2-HallD Saved Dec 29, 2018 |
Please log in this format (please don't change this example just copy and paste it]:
--------
[title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab
[nick of the observer angel]
--------
[timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement]
...
[timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends
--> [Conclusion here]
_____________________________________________________
A farewell to soul-crushing code - Towards correct software that enriches our lives
Hendrix
--------
11:27 herald introduces the speaker and talk
11:28 speaker starts the talk
11:30 good movement between cameras and presentation
11:32 bad window for speakers - 1,5 speakers are in the window ... get's adjusted
11:35 bad window for speakers - hands are out of the window (gestures)
11:37 gestures of speaker are not caught
11:41 too long focus just on presentation
11:44 good association between speaker and presentation
11:45 camera 1 does not follow the speaker ... follows to slow
11:48 too long focus just on presentation
11:50 too long focus just on presentation
11:52 presenters are talking with each other but you see just one - better switch to camera 2 ... happens later
11:55 gestures/hands are out of the picture
11:58 camera 2 does not evenly capture both speakers
12:02 view on both speakers could be closer > better at late 12:03 !
12:06 too long focus just on presentation
12:09 too long focus just on presentaion
12:12 camera does not capture both speakers
12:15 reading to the internet question is hardly understandable
12:17 camera window has to go more to the left to catch both presenters evenly
12:18 much echo during Q&A question asked
12:21 echo during Q&A question asked
12:25 good caturing of presenters and their gestures!
...
timestamp system time 12:27 talk ends
--> [Conclusion here]
Good capturing of the atmosphere.
Presenters are "talking a lot with their hands" and that is not always captured.
Sometimes the presentation is shown too long without interruption, e.g. of picture in picture.
Since there were 2 presenters it was difficult to catch them both in a good way.
_____________________________________________________
--------
[Modern Windows Userspace Exploitation]
[usr16549] remotely
--------
SBSp = side-by-side preview
SBSe = side-by-side equal
PIP = picture in picture
FS = fullscreen
[12:47] $herald visible / $stream start
[12:47] good camera movement
[12:48] [$camera identifiable faces were visible on stream]
[12:48] $stream paused
[12:49] $stream start
[12:49] $stream paused
[12:49] $stream start
[12:50] $herald introduces the speaker and talk, stream starts mid-sentence
[12:50] $speaker starts the talk
[12:51] $mixer good switch from SBSp to FS slides
[12:53] $mixer keeps switching from SBSp to FS slides.
[12:53] $mixer good switch to PIP due to reasonably empty slides
[12:55] $mixer rapid switching between PIP, FS speaker, SBSp
[12:58] $mixer switch to FS speaker; speaker visible in full size -> unnecessary
[13:00] $mixer good correction of speaker framing
[13:01] $mixer unfortunate switch to PIP causing obstruction of parts of the slides content, corrects immediately by switching to SBSp
[13:02] $mixer again, speaker framing too large
[13:02] $mixer corrects setting
[13:03] $mixer switch to FS speaker when change of slides can be anticipated within a few seconds
[13:05] $mixer slides obstructed due to PIP, corrected with some delay
[13:07] $mixer again, speaker framing too large, then switches to better-framed camera.
[13:08] $mixer again PIP to SBSp within a few seconds
[13:10] $mixer might want to consider switching from PIP to FS slides when the content of the slides is obstructed by the PIP, as thereby the change in picture is less obvious
[13:12] $mixer again, framing of speaker too large
[13:16] $mixer again, framing of speaker too large
[13:16] $mixer switch to camera set of for SBS, then switch to FS slides, then to PIP.
[13:17] $mixer unnecessary switch from PIP to SBSp, as the content that was obstructed by PIP was of no relevance
[13:18] $mixer again, framing of speaker, then corrected within 30s
[13:21] $camera PIP speaker overtracking, causing the speaker to wander out of picture
[13:23] $mixer again, unfortunate switch from FS to obstructing PIP to SBSp
[13:31] $camera speaker walks out of frame for approx. 5s
[13:32] $mixer some delay when switching to demo
[13:36] $mixer switch to audience camera unneccessary
[13:37] $mixer PIP shortly obstructs picture, corrected by switching to FS slides
[13:39] $mixer FS speaker to FS slides to PIP slides+speaker unfortunate
[13:40] $talk ends
[13:40] herald visible with full body, unnecessary
[13:40] $mixer switch to audience camera on talk end is bad, as faces might be identifiable
[13:41] $stream end
--> [There were some mixing mishaps, primarily the poorly framed speaker in FS and numerous rapid-switching sequences, in part due to excessive use of PIP. On one occasion, the speaker left the frame of the camera, suggesting that the communication between camera and mixer did fail and the camera operator was unaware of him being live. At the beginning of the talk, the stream was started and paused two times, then starting the stream mid sentence of the herald introducing the talk.]
_____________________________________________________
--------
[title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab
[nick of the observer angel]
--------
[timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement]
...
[timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends
--> [Conclusion here]
_____________________________________________________
--------
Sense without sight: a crash course on #BlindNavigation
Fox
--------
14:11 herald introduces the speaker and talk- just last to seconds on stream+
14:11 high feedback sound on stream
14.11 speaker starts the talk
14:13 speaker talks, herold appears on stage like requested by the speaker. the full frame slide doesn't make sense to me
14:16 speaker denmonstrates using his cane. camera should follow his movements
14.17 maybe a bit more "foot room"
14:17 herald bad lighting
14.19 camera should frame with more "foot room"
14:20 nice framing. bad lighting
14:23 very low light situation - more light :-)
14:25 camera too far. one can barely see anything impotant
14:26 speaker is explaining, should show him. there was action in the room. why not show the overview camera at least for a short period od time
14.27 speaker exlains. herold is not in action. better to show the speaker
14:28 Great Idea to use hand camera!
14:31 Nice framing, give the speaker a bit more nose room
14.32 There apperas some rumbling, on the left audio channel
14:33 speaker is acting. no real content on the slide yet. Show him in full frame.
14:41 hand camera is out of focus ... .adjusted it! Great.
14:44 a microphone is rubbing - not shure it's the one of the speaker
14:47 hand camera good - a bit tilted
14.50 great picture in picture :-)
14:51 nice framing, may be a tiny bit more foot room
14.53 Again very nice picture in picture! Also to show this important slide in full fram! Great!
14:55 Q & A starts
14:57 nice framing covering herold, asking person and speaker
14:57 spaeker explains. for me the slide make no sense here. Show the speaker.
14.58 spaeker explains. for me the slide make no sense here. Show the speaker.
15:00 audio from the internet was not understandable ... should use a direct line
15:02 nice camera framing
15:04 may be the slide with workshops should be shown after the talk for 15..30 seconds, so the slide did steal camera time for the speaker.
15:10 grat to show Workshop slide again
15:11 talk ends
--> Overall very nice work! It's a different situation than in the other talks. The speaker is moving in different direcetions and going off the stage. Camera did a great job to follow him and get a nice framing. Good adaptive video mixing depending on the action of the speaker.
Lighting situation could be better. Sometime very low light situation. Calm video mixing support the talk. Hand camera could imporove to be adjusted parallel to the ground.
White balance is not consistent over all cameras. Hand camera seems to have a different white balance setting.
/!\ Sometimes it's too loud in the VOC area!
_____________________________________________________
--------
Theater und Quantenzeitalter
enJott
--------
16:12 Stream opened before introduction of speaker, information for the audience is on stream
16:18 herald introduces the speaker and talk
16:19 speaker starts the talk
16:19 three speakers, all in frame, frame could be a little closer
16:20 One speaker in frame, a second speaker partly visible on the right, camera should pan a little to the left
16:22 panned to the left, frame is good now
16:24 long shot, not very useful here
16:24 video started, switched to slides immediatly, good!
16:25 video ended, PIP with snapshot from video, gives context, good!
16:26 back to close up, good frame again
16:27 back to PIP, image doesn't really fit to the things the speaker says at the moment, close up more useful
16:28 back to close up
16:29 main speaker turns to the other speakers, camera switches to cam 2, good!
16:30 new slide, slide to fullscreen
16:31 PIP, useful here, picture on slide is complex so it is good to see it longer, speaker "talkes a lot with his hands" while explaining the picture, so nice to see that too
16:33 video again, slides to fullscreen
16:33 video audio only on the left speaker, not shure if thats in original or fixable by VOC
16:35 video ends, long shot
16:35 new image PIP again, like before
16:37 speaker changes topic away from slide, close up
16:39 new speaker, noise from mic rubbing in beard
16:40 speaker was informed by stage manager, corrected as good as possible while live
16:40 Video on slide with PIP, seeing speaker distracts from video
16:42 first speaker again, stream shows all speaker for a moment, than close up, good
16:44 third speaker, all three are shown again
16:44 video again, this time fullscreen, again switched to sliedes directly at video start, good
16:46 long shot
16:46 new slide after video, shown in fullscreen
16:46 PIP after a Moment
16:48 all three speakers again, nice framing
16:48 close up of speaker one, than to PIP
16:49 topic changes and stream goes back to cam 1 in fullscreen
16:51 video starts, switch to slides fullscreen
16:51 speaker stops video accidentally, short break for restart, long shot meanwhile
16:53 long shot after video, than to cam 1 after a few moments
16:54 again new image, slide shown in fullscreen, PIP after a moment
16:55 slide changes, third speaker talking, a few cuts between cam 2, cam 1 and PIP until deciding to PIP
16:56 applause, long shot
16:56 back to PIP after applause
16:56 cam 1 in PIP shows second and third speaker, both very small that way, frame could be narrower. Not sure if a better frame is possible, speaker two and three stand closely together
16:57 video, full screen slide
16:58 speaker one talks after video, all three speakers are shown, speaker one nearly out of frame
16:58 cam 1, good frame again
17:01 cam 2 with all three speakers in PIP, very small
17:01 cam 2 to fullscreen
17:05 Q & A starts
17:05 herald shown, in cam 1, very wide for a close up
17:07 speakers are shown all three while answers, good frame as in talk
17:14 talk ends
Very good in general, always switched quick to slides when necessary, maybe a little much use of picture-in-picture. Once a little confusion with selecting the cam at 16:55
_____________________________________________________
--------
Never Forgetti
LorenzN
--------
[17:33] herald provides information about translations
[17:34] herald gives introduction
[17:34] speaker starts the talk
[17:35] video/slides only with voice over
[17:37] speaker tries to get video into fullscreen. Technical issues
[17:37] mixer doesn't know wich perspective to show
[17:39] Don't use Picture in Picture, use side by side preview instead.
[17:42] Following of Cameras could be better
[17:42] Camera 2 could loosen the brake for panning a bit
[17:45] Distracting Microphone noises. Rubbing against something
[17:45] Close up shot could be used more often, at least, when speaker is not moving
[17:47] Show cam3 only, when there is a rason, not randomly
[17:50] Seemingly reasonless switching between slides onlly and Picture in Picture
[17:51] When speaker moves into audience follow him ith cam1/2 and not only change to cam3
[18:05] Too much headspace on cam1
[18:06] Q & A starts
[18:08] Speaker walks out of Frame
[18:17] talk ends
-> This was obviously a very hard talk to film/mix. There were a lot of awkward pauses and the Mixer didn't always know what to show. There was a lot of movement; the speaker even moved into the audience. However the following improved until it was really nice at the "endpiece". The video mixer could slow down with the switching between perspectives a bit. The lighting situation also wasn't optimal.
_____________________________________________________
--------
Feminist Perspectives
anaea
--------
general context: on stage is a panel of speakers, sitting in a sort of semi-circle. 6 people in total, 4th from the left is the moderator. Individual speakers may stand up and walk over to the desk/pult to give their part of the talk, others prefer to remain seated among the panel and talk from there.
Later on there is a discussion among the panelists, with the moderator passing on questions to individual panelists.
18:37 stream starts, herald introduces speaker, camera shows speaker above belt but cuts off speaker on the left hand side (from audience's perspective)
18:38 camera follows additional speakers smoothly
18:39 zooming out from stage is a bit quick/shaky
18:40 switching from panel to single speaker took some time, speaker walked out of the frame
18:40 speaker nicely centered in the frame, enough head space
18:42 switching to wide angle does not make sense to me
18:43 nicely switching to slides as soon as there is a change
18:45 slides shown for too long for my taste, with no speaker being shown, not even PIP (slides did not have much content that would take time to read)
18:47 audio only came from the left side for a few seconds
18:49 nice switch from slides back to speaker (above belt) when speaker started to gesture a lot
18:51 good switch to wide angle cam when one speaker finished and went back to the panel on stage
18:52 several scenes where people in frame are cut off on the side
18:55 camera nicely shows stage only, i.e. captures everyone on stage without showing too much audience
18:56 good idea to show wide angle cam when audience applauds and there is nothing going on on the stage
19:00 showing wide angle when speaker still speaks at the desk seems weird to me, I would have preferred camera on the speaker
19:02 audio and video are slightly out of sync
19:04 camera captures panel speaker and close neighbours really nicely, enough head room, not showing anything "below" the stage
19:10 (valid for the previous 5 minutes) nice switching back and forth between showing entire panel on stage and only showing the current speaker (maybe next to her neighbour)
19:11 wide angle cam perspective does not do anything as there is no context to be shown outside of the panelists talking
19:18 audio/video of left most panelist is slightly out of sync again
19:25 mixer has "calmed down", there are less frequent switches between cams which works very well with the panel discussing different questions among themselves
19:32 FAQ starts
19:40 "calmed down" pattern from earlier continues. default setting seems to full panel being in frame. When question is answered by particular panelist, mixer quickly switches to cam showing the talking panelist.
19:53 talk ends
--> Panel discussion is probably a bit different from the "usual" talk with one or two speakers which is probably why it took mixer and cam operators a while to find settings and perspectives that work. At the beginning there was too much camera-related action for my taste but it calmed down at about half of the talk.
Audio was slightly out of sync with video (only noticeable if one pays attention) a few times, I mostly noticed it on one particular panelist.
_____________________________________________________
--------
[Jailbreaking iOS] [spulg]
--------
[20:37] weird visual glitch from time to time on the pause screen, might be VLC]
[20:47] herald starts tallking
[20:48] sudden switch to the pause screen in the middle of a sentence
[20:50] stream is back, herald introduces the talk
[20:51] speaker starts the talk
[20:52] nice catch on the speaker frame blocking the slide slightly
[20:55] speaker frame is blocking the bottom right of the slide for a long time
[20:57] first time showing the speaker as a main frame when the slide didn't need to be read anymore
[20:58] again speaker frame blocking parts of text, this time however not as long
[21:00] good decision to change to this layout to prevent further slide blocking
[21:06] slide layout changes for 1 slide because of little text, however next slide speaker frame blocks text again
[21:22] very fluent, non-disruptive layout changes
[21:34] herald starts Q&A
[21:37] no more questions; herald is cut off in the middle of his sentence for pause screen]
[] talk ends
--> [due to the static nature of the talk, nothing out of the ordinary happened; it was a very natural viewing experience and no big errors need to be mentioned ]
_____________________________________________________
--------
[Simulating Universes - What Virtual Universes Can Tell Us About Our Own][incase]
--------
[22:08] Stream starts
[22:08] Herald asks for applause for translators. Nice!
[22:08] [Show slides while translation is announced.]
[22:10] Herald announces speaker
[22:11] Timely switch to well framed speaker
[22:11] Good just-in-time switch to the animation
[22:12] Mostly empty slide shown quite long
[22:13] PiP is hiding part of the informational text of the slide. [Don't hide parts of the slide with info before it could have been read]
[22:16] Still using PiP - and hiding part of the information. [Don't overuse PiP/Supersource]
[22:17] Again hiding seemingly important textual information from the slide.
[22:18] A switch I like: Slide was shown long enough, switched to Side-by-Side, showing the speaker and showing that the slide didn't change yet.
[22:19] Slightly late switch to full screen slide.
[22:21] Slightly late switch to full screen slide again. Probably both OKish though.
[22:24] Wasn't even able to read the slide once. [Please keep slides long enough to read roughly twice]
[22:28] Well timed and good switches to fullscreen animation and SbS view.
[22:33] Again: Couldn't read the slide even once [Keep slides with lots of text on full screen longer]
[22:35] Short glitch switching to cam2 for half a second, then cam1.
[22:36] Good use of Side-by-Side-Preview.
[22:39] [Please keep slides full screen long enough to read them, twice!]
[22:44] [same]
[22:51] Nice SbS-Preview use
[22:53] [same]
[22:54] Slide not readable in SbS-Preview, full-screen would have been needed
[22:58] Too late switch to FS, also on screen too short.
[22:59] slide on screen too short
[23:02] again...
[23:02] odd switching between views.
[23:03] Begin Q&A (sound) Question barely audible at first. Good camera image use during Q&A
[23:10] Herald ends Q&A - end of stream
--> Generally a relatively pleasant stream, not challenging on cameras. [Video-Mixer should keep slides full screen more]
_________________________________________________
The Year in post-quantum Crypto
djb, Tanja Lange
[23:29] Stream starts, Herald tells people in thr room to move
23:30 Herald announces speakers, during introduction speakers are shown, nice. but person on the left falls a little off the frame
23:31 Talk starts
23:33 Speaker almost beyond frame
23:34 cool view with design background, then shift to slice
23:35 in the moment when speaker starts to talk about red stuff on slide camera switches to cam 1 :(
more room avove head of speaker would be good, seems like glueing to the frame
23:38: speaker on the very left of the frame, gestures/ hands sometimes outside frame
23:41 nice swich from one speaker to the other, then to slide
23:43 makes sense to show the slice all the time
23:48 fokus on speaker, jokes, fast move to slide, cool
23:51: frame ends almost directly above the head of speaker
23:52 overview camera, ganz gute Abwechslung
23:54 overview doesn't really make sense to me
23:55: frame ends almost directly above the head of speaker
23:57 time only slice is shown exactly enough for me, then showing speaker additionally
00:03 frame higher now, fitts better for me now, more room avove head of speaker now
00:06 gestures of speaker bigger than frame again
00:09 closeup refreshing
00: 00:10 slice very full --> good to show only slice, switching between slice an speaker
00:11 speaker asks "what do you see (on the slide)?", takes a little too long before showing the slice
00:14 slide with frame for speaker, but no speaker there?
00:17 stream hangs twice
00:32 speaker talks about a slide, takes a time untill slice can be seen
good decision to show both speakers together during q&a
00:40 talk ends
quick changes between speakers caught well
for me it was good to see most of the time slice plus speaker
speaker likes big gestures, so often hands or arms were cut off
missing dot in "by Chaos Computer Club e.V.(<-- !!!), iSystems, ..." is really disturbing ;)
